Money rules are everywhere. “Save 20% of your income.” “Never use credit cards.” “Always invest for the long term.” And while these rules are rooted in good intentions, following them rigidly can sometimes create shame, guilt, or missed opportunities.
The truth is, money isn’t one-size-fits-all. Small, consistent money habits make the most significant difference. So, designing your own rules—and knowing when to bend or break them—can help you stay financially disciplined and live a life that feels fulfilling.
Why Money Rules Matter
Money rules provide structure. They help you:
-
Avoid impulse decisions.
-
Build consistent savings habits.
-
Make progress toward goals like buying a home, paying down debt, or investing.
But the problem arises when rules become rigid commandments. When every purchase or choice feels like a potential “violation,” money rules can start to feel restrictive instead of empowering.
The key is balance: design rules that serve you, not the other way around.
Step 1: Identify Your Core Money Values
Before creating rules, get clear on what matters most to you. Ask yourself:
-
What are my financial priorities?
-
Which habits bring me peace of mind?
-
What spending brings me joy without guilt?
For some, security might be top priority; for others, freedom or experiences matter most. Your rules should reflect these values, not just what the internet says is “right.”
Example rules based on values:
-
Security-focused: “I’ll keep an emergency fund of six months’ expenses at all times.”
-
Freedom-focused: “I’ll limit recurring subscriptions to what I truly use.”
-
Joy-focused: “I’ll spend up to $150 a month on personal hobbies guilt-free.”
Step 2: Create Rules That Work for You
Once you know your values, set up flexible money strategies:
-
Budget intentionally. Not every dollar needs a category, but create rules around areas that matter most (rent, lifestyle, savings, debt repayment).
-
Automate the essentials. Rules like “transfer 10% of income to savings each month” reduce decision fatigue.
-
Simplify tracking. Rules should make life easier, not harder. If logging every latte stresses you out, consider a broader category for discretionary spending.
Remember: rules aren’t meant to be chains around your neck; they’re tools to help you make intentional choices.
Step 3: Know When to Break the Rules
Ironically, the most effective money rules are flexible. Breaking a rule can actually strengthen your financial mindset when done thoughtfully.
Examples of Smart Rule-Breaking
-
Spending on experiences: You may have a rule to avoid discretionary spending. But taking a weekend trip with friends or buying tickets to a concert may enrich your life and well-being.
-
Investing in yourself: A strict “no non-essential spending” rule may prevent you from taking a course, hiring a coach, or buying tools that increase your income potential.
-
Helping family or giving back: You may have a rule against large unplanned expenses. But assisting a family member in need or supporting a cause you care about may be more aligned with your values than sticking to the rule.
- Dipping into your emergency fund: What good is your emergency fund if you refuse to dip into it? This fund should be there to ease your peace of mind, not create more stress. Get comfortable dipping into it when there’s a health, family, car/house, or job-related emergency.
Key principle: Breaking a rule should be intentional, aligned with values, and sustainable within your financial plan.
Step 4: Evaluate and Adjust
Money rules aren’t static—they should evolve with your life, priorities, and circumstances. Check in regularly to ask:
-
Are my rules helping me feel confident about money?
-
Do any rules create unnecessary stress or guilt?
-
Are there opportunities where bending a rule could enhance my life without jeopardizing financial goals?
These check-ins keep your financial life flexible, intentional, and aligned with your values.
Step 5: Build Confidence With Flexible Discipline
Designing rules—and breaking them when it helps—is a mindset of flexible discipline:
-
Discipline: You have guidelines that keep you on track and protect your future.
-
Flexibility: You recognize life is unpredictable and that values, priorities, and joy sometimes outweigh rigid rules.
This approach helps you avoid the trap of perfectionism with money while still building long-term security and financial wellness.
You Have the Power
Money rules are powerful—but only when they serve you, not the other way around. By designing rules rooted in your values and giving yourself permission to break them strategically, you can reduce financial stress, increase joy, and still make progress toward your goals.
Your money should empower your life, not limit it. When you adopt a mindset of intentional, flexible rules, you gain control, confidence, and freedom—all while living in alignment with what truly matters.
If you want help navigating unhelpful, rigid “money shoulds,” I can help put together a financial plan for you that provides guidance on all areas of your financial life, including withholdings, insurance, investments, and retirement.
